RPG Games vs Traditional Math Apps: Which Works Better?

RPG math games outperform traditional math apps in keeping students engaged and improving math skills. Here’s why:

• RPG Math Games: They embed math problems into storylines, turning learning into an adventure. Students solve math challenges to progress through quests, battle monsters, or unlock new levels. This approach boosts engagement, reduces math anxiety, and improves retention.

• Traditional Math Apps: These focus on repetitive drills with rewards like points and badges. While effective for targeted practice, they often feel monotonous, leading to lower long-term interest.

Quick Comparison

For middle school math, RPG games like Infinilearn and Prodigy Math make learning fun and immersive, helping students stay engaged and confident. Traditional apps work best as a supplement for quick skill reinforcement.

RPG Math Games vs Traditional Math Apps: Engagement and Learning Outcomes Comparison

Honestly Reviewing a Math Game for Children...

What Are RPG Math Games?

RPG math games combine storytelling with problem-solving, letting students take on roles like wizards or explorers to complete quests by tackling math challenges. Unlike standard apps that present math problems in isolation, these games weave them into the storyline. To defeat a monster or move forward in a quest, players must solve math problems that are deeply embedded in the game's mechanics.

Take Infinilearn, for example. In this game, students step into the shoes of Academy apprentices in a world called Numeria, where the Arcane Seal protecting the land has shattered. Players engage in turn-based combat against monsters, but instead of simply clicking attack buttons, they solve math problems tailored to their grade level and aligned with Common Core standards. Success in the game hinges on solving these problems, making math an essential part of the gameplay and story progression.

Now, let’s dive into what makes RPG math games stand out.

Core Features of RPG Math Games

These games have several standout features. They offer narrative arcs with clear storylines, character progression where students can customize avatars and enhance their abilities, and adaptive difficulty that adjusts math challenges based on each student’s performance. According to research, 74% of teachers have incorporated digital game-based learning into their lessons, and classrooms using these tools see 93% of class time spent on-task, compared to just 72% in traditional settings.

What sets these games apart is their structure. Adam Dubé, Assistant Professor and Director of the Technology, Learning, and Cognition Lab at McGill University, explains it best:

"The game's mechanics are the mathematical thinking".

For instance, in DragonBox Algebra, players manipulate boxes to balance equations. Success comes only when the equation is balanced, making the gameplay itself a direct exercise in mathematical reasoning.

How Math Problems Integrate Into Gameplay

In RPG math games, solving math problems isn’t just a means to earn rewards - it’s the core action. A great example is Prodigy Math, a massively multiplayer online role-playing game designed for students in grades 1 through 8. In this game, players explore a fantasy world as magical wizards, engaging in "wizard battles." To cast spells and defeat opponents, they must correctly answer math questions aligned with educational standards. Research shows that students who used Prodigy three times a week improved their standardized test scores by 18% compared to those who didn’t use the platform.

This integration creates what researchers call "authentic engagement." By embedding math into the narrative, the game gives students a meaningful reason to solve problems, reducing cognitive load and making the experience more intuitive and enjoyable. This approach stands in stark contrast to traditional apps, where math often feels like a separate, less engaging activity.

What Are Traditional Math Apps?

Traditional math apps focus on drill-and-practice methods to help students strengthen their math skills. These apps rely on repetitive exercises, much like digital worksheets, making them easy for teachers to integrate into standard classroom routines. Let’s take a closer look at their typical features and the challenges they face.

Common Features of Traditional Math Apps

Most traditional math apps share a set of familiar features. They present practice problems - often in multiple-choice format - and provide immediate feedback. To make the experience more engaging, many include gamified elements like points, levels, and leaderboards. Some newer versions even add competitive components to increase interaction among students.

Interestingly, a meta-analysis of 122 peer-reviewed studies found that integrating technology into teaching has a moderate impact on learning effectiveness. This aligns with the growing use of gamification, which aims to make repetitive tasks feel more engaging. However, as Jackson Best, an educator and writer for Mathletics, explains:

"Repeated worksheets, routine practice, and predictable activities (even when important) can cause concepts to blur and enthusiasm to fade".

Drawbacks of Traditional Math Apps

Despite their benefits, traditional math apps have notable limitations. One major issue is keeping students engaged over the long term. While gamified features like leaderboards and points may initially excite learners, this enthusiasm often wears off - a phenomenon known as diminishing engagement.

Unlike role-playing math games that integrate challenges into compelling narratives, traditional apps rely heavily on external rewards. This approach can make students see them as just another version of worksheets, rather than a fun learning tool. Additionally, research indicates that while digital math drills might improve students' attitudes toward math, they don’t consistently lead to better cognitive performance or deeper learning strategies compared to traditional teaching methods.

As Professor Fengfeng Ke from Florida State University puts it, "not every computer math drill game would engage children in committed learning". This highlights the need to rethink how these tools are designed to truly captivate and educate students.

Engagement: RPG Games vs Traditional Math Apps

How RPG Games Maintain Student Interest

RPG math games excel at keeping students engaged by weaving math challenges into adventure-filled storylines. Imagine battling monsters or unlocking hidden treasures - all by solving math problems. Each correct answer pushes the story forward, making learning feel like an exciting quest rather than a chore.

This method taps into students' natural curiosity and motivation. Instead of relying on external rewards, these games let students shape their own experience. They can pick avatars, choose missions, and set their learning pace. This sense of control satisfies their need for autonomy and competence, keeping them in a "flow state" - a sweet spot where they're challenged just enough to stay focused but not so much that they feel overwhelmed. Game designer Katie Salen captures this idea beautifully:

"We expect games to be spaces where we fail. It's actually fun to get better at something in a game when it's structured in the right way".

The impact is clear. A 2022 survey of math teachers revealed that 63% noticed greater persistence in problem-solving among students using RPG-based tools compared to traditional methods. In Lima, for example, students in gamified math lessons stayed actively engaged for an average of 42 minutes per hour, while those in non-gamified lessons only managed 28 minutes. Even more striking, 82% of students reported feeling more excited about math in gamified settings, compared to just 47% in traditional ones.

Why Traditional Apps Struggle With Long-Term Engagement

While RPG games captivate students with stories and meaningful choices, traditional math apps often fall short. These apps rely on external rewards like points, badges, and leaderboards to grab attention. While this approach might spark initial interest, it quickly loses its charm - a phenomenon researchers call the "novelty effect." Once the excitement fades, motivation drops off.

As R. Manrique López from the National University of Trujillo explains:

"Traditional approach to teaching mathematics... often relies heavily on rote memorization and passive learning. Many students find mathematical exercises monotonous, leading to disengagement".

The repetitive, drill-based format of these apps feels more like digital worksheets than an engaging activity. Without a compelling narrative or opportunities for meaningful decision-making, students are less likely to stay interested. Traditional apps often fail to meet the deeper needs for autonomy and competence that drive long-term engagement.

Engagement Comparison Table

These differences highlight why RPG math games consistently outperform traditional apps when it comes to keeping students engaged. By blending math with adventure and choice, RPG games transform learning into an experience students actually look forward to.

Skill Retention and Math Anxiety Reduction

How RPG Math Games Improve Retention

RPG math games are a clever way to help students hold onto math concepts longer because they weave problems directly into the storyline. For instance, when players manage resources or trade items during the game, they’re actively applying math in real-world-like situations. This approach makes math feel less like a chore and more like an essential tool for success in the game’s world.

A study conducted in September 2019 by Jewoong Moon and Fengfeng Ke at Florida State University examined the impact of the game E-Rebuild on 25 middle school students over 92 gameplay sessions. The results were telling: in-game tasks such as assigning resources to refugees and trading materials kept students engaged with the content, while activities like building tools and providing learning support encouraged deeper cognitive engagement and mathematical thinking.

The storytelling aspect of these games also plays a big role in shaping students’ attitudes toward math, making it less intimidating and more approachable. Some RPGs even include a feature where players "teach" an in-game character to solve problems. This reduces the fear of failure and boosts confidence. As Fengfeng Ke explains:

"Computer games can invoke intense engagement in learners... and encourage active learning or learning by doing".

By blending math into gameplay, these games not only improve retention but also create a more supportive environment for tackling math anxiety.

Reducing Math Anxiety Through RPG Games

Math anxiety can be a huge roadblock to learning. RPG math games tackle this challenge by offering a relaxed, low-pressure environment where mistakes are just part of the game, not a reason to feel defeated. This approach helps students learn without the stress often associated with traditional drills.

A study published in July 2014 in the Journal of Computers in Education tested a game-based learning method with 69 fifth-grade students over 240 minutes. The results were striking: students in the game-based group scored an average of 92.88 and reported lower math anxiety (3.32 mean) compared to their peers in traditional instruction, who scored 86.80 and had a higher anxiety mean of 3.54. Another study, conducted at the University of Szczecin between March and November 2024, focused on RPG-based interventions with 30 participants aged 18–28. It showed a significant drop in both anxiety and avoidance, with a large effect size (Cohen’s d = 0.94).

These findings highlight how RPG games create a safe space for learning, turning math from a source of stress into an engaging and enjoyable experience.

Retention and Anxiety in Traditional Apps

Traditional math apps take a different approach, often relying on repetitive drills to reinforce skills. These apps typically use memory-matching exercises, timed challenges, and repetitive problem-solving to build automaticity. While this method can help with quick recall and basic fact reinforcement, it comes with its own set of challenges.

Timed drills and performance tracking tend to prioritize speed over understanding, which can increase pressure and worsen math anxiety. For example, one study found that students using a traditional e-learning app reported a higher self-efficacy rating (3.67) compared to those in traditional instruction (3.27). However, their motivation was lower (3.56) than that of students in game-based learning environments (3.78). Additionally, the repetitive nature of these apps can lead to boredom once the initial novelty wears off.

That said, traditional apps can still play a role in targeted practice. They’re particularly effective for students who need to strengthen specific skills quickly. However, they work best as a complement to other learning methods, especially for students who benefit from a low-pressure environment before tackling more structured exercises. Unlike RPG games, traditional apps lack the narrative-driven context that makes learning engaging and helps reduce anxiety.

Which Works Better for Middle School Math?

Why RPG Math Games Deliver Better Results

RPG math games bring a unique edge to learning by combining immersive gameplay with educational content, offering a dual engagement that traditional apps often lack. For instance, a Carnegie Mellon University study conducted between 2015 and 2019 examined the impact of the RPG-style game Decimal Point on 624 middle school students. The results? Students learned more effectively with the game than with a traditional tutor. Interestingly, female students dealing with math anxiety showed particularly strong improvements.

Games like Infinilearn go beyond traditional approaches by blending content mastery with cognitive engagement. Research supports the idea that the interactive nature of these games - where players actively solve problems as part of the storyline - boosts both understanding and interest in math.

When Traditional Apps Can Be Helpful

Traditional math apps still hold value, especially for sharpening specific skills through focused practice. For students needing to strengthen their speed and accuracy in basic operations - like multiplication facts or decimal calculations - these apps excel. Their repetitive drills and straightforward design help build automaticity, making them ideal for quick, targeted practice. However, they work best as supplements, preparing students for more complex problem-solving tasks.

Recommendations for Parents and Teachers

Balancing the strengths of both methods can lead to better outcomes. Here are some strategies for parents and teachers to consider:

• For Parents and Homeschoolers: If you're aiming to meet Common Core standards while keeping your child engaged, RPG games like Infinilearn can be a great option. These games incorporate grade-specific math problems (for 6th, 7th, and 8th grades) into interactive, turn-based gameplay. Plus, the built-in progress tracking dashboard allows you to monitor your child’s performance in real time, making it easier to identify areas for improvement.

• For Teachers: Look for games that encourage students to explain their reasoning after solving problems. This approach deepens understanding and helps with long-term retention. As Huy Anh Nguyen from Carnegie Mellon University points out:

  "Middle school is when math anxiety emerges among female students and therefore a crucial time for addressing this issue".

For students who struggle with self-confidence in math, RPG-based games can be transformative. By stepping into the role of a fantasy character, they can reframe mistakes as part of an adventurous journey rather than personal shortcomings. This shift in perspective can help them rebuild their confidence and find joy in learning.

FAQs

How do RPG math games help reduce math anxiety compared to traditional apps?

RPG math games tackle math anxiety by turning abstract problems into immersive stories. Students step into character roles, embarking on quests that shift the focus from personal performance to helping their avatar succeed. This setup creates a more relaxed and fun way to learn math. Instead of traditional grades, students earn in-game rewards like points or level-ups, making feedback feel encouraging and pressure-free.

These games also adapt to individual needs, letting students pick challenges that match their comfort level and practice at their own speed. By blending storytelling, choice, and non-punitive feedback, they help boost confidence and motivation. Unlike traditional apps that rely heavily on drills and scores - often adding to the stress - RPG math games make math a lot less intimidating.

How do RPG math games keep students engaged over time?

RPG math games stand out because they mix interactive gameplay with effective learning strategies. By engaging in tasks like managing resources, solving problems, and navigating story-driven challenges, students stay immersed in math concepts while sharpening their reasoning skills. The game's structure, which gives players a sense of control and purpose, helps students grasp these concepts more deeply and remember them longer than traditional practice methods.

These games also play a key role in shifting attitudes toward math. By making the learning process enjoyable, they help reduce math anxiety and build confidence. As students grow more comfortable tackling challenging problems, they practice more frequently, which naturally strengthens their math abilities over time. This positive feedback loop not only boosts current skills but also sets the stage for future learning success.

When is it better to use traditional math apps instead of RPG-based math games?

Traditional math apps work best when the focus is on targeted, repetitive practice of specific skills like multiplication tables or simplifying fractions. These apps typically feature quick drills, step-by-step exercises, and immediate feedback, making them excellent tools for improving speed and accuracy. They also align with Common Core standards and often include detailed progress tracking, which can be incredibly useful for teachers and homeschooling parents.

These apps are especially helpful for students who are just beginning to learn a concept and need clear, guided instruction. By breaking skills into smaller, more manageable steps, they ensure learners can grasp the fundamentals before tackling more complex, story-based formats like RPG-style learning games. Plus, traditional apps are a great fit for shorter study sessions or times when engagement needs to be brief, as they don’t require the extended commitment of narrative-driven games.

Related Blog Posts

• How to Choose Educational Games for Teens: Parent's Guide